Google Reviews

Brittany Tolentino

I have been using Varsity Insurance since I started my business. Cole is very knowledgeable and explains things in a way you will understand. The communication and response time is undeniably fast. I have found that as my business grows, I needed Cole for far beyond my scope of insurance and policies. It seems as though his business philosophy is in line with ours, to focus on the relationships with the customers & do not nickel and dime. We are happy to continue to have Cole and the Varsity Insurance team as part of the Fresh Aire of Northeast Florida family for years to come!

Jan Hirabayashi

From my experience working with Varsity Insurance over the span of several years, you can ALWAYS count on Cole and Ken to deliver great pricing and service. They are very easy to work with and always thoroughly explain my options. I appreciate that I get the same level of responsiveness from them either via email or the phone.

Leanne Perez

Had a wonderful experience working with Cole Warthen at Varsity Insurance. He candidly explained what the different options were for my parents to consider. He worked diligently to obtain a great rate for my parent's homeowners' insurance and with great coverage from a reputable company. I would recommend Varsity Insurance to anyone looking for competitive rates and stellar customer service. Thank you!

Chris Box

I have been with Varsity Insurance Group for several years and have had the absolute best service. Specifically, Cole Warthen is always quick to respond to my questions when I email him and he seems to be genuinely interested in helping me and my family. The best part is that when I call I know who I'm going to talk with and I won't be on hold waiting to talk to some person at a call center. This family first local business is a true winner in my eyes and I won't be switching anytime soon. Thank you for all you do!

Debby Graham

I have been with Varsity for a lot of years, 3 homes and several cars. Each time I shop around to see if I can get a cheaper rate, both Cole and Ken, have been able to help me save money. I have people asking me all the time how my rates can be so low. They are local and live local and understand the market. Real people! To add: seasons in life change our needs; Cole and his team have been able to make wise suggestions on getting my son in college covered for his possessions and were able to connect me with the right person. We signed up with Cole when my son was about 4; he is now in his 3rd yr of college and Cole continues to help us out with excellent customer service and follow thru. Thank you for what you do!

See more reviews on Google

Welcome to Varsity Insurance Group Inc

We are an Independent Insurance Agency, which means we have made available some of the best companies for your online quick quotes

We service the Jacksonville, Duval County, FL areas, and throughout the state of FL. At Varsity Insurance Group Inc each one of our clients are given a dedicated team of professionals that work together to proficiently address all your concerns.

We offer all types of Personal Insurance coverages to our clients in FL, including Auto, Home, Motorcycle, Boat & Watercraft, Flood Insurance, Life, and Health Insurance.

Give one of our agents a call to save money on your business insurance. Some of our Commercial insurance coverages include Business Owners Packages (BOP), General Liability, Commercial Auto, Commercial Real Estate Insurance, and Contractors Insurance.

Let us help you cut your insurance cost! Just give us a quick call today at 904-268-6365 or submit one of our quick online quote forms - with the help of our dedicated business partners; we conveniently offer an entire solution for all your personal and business insurance needs.